Movie Stars   >   Jon Amiel   >   Forum

Jon Amiel Forum

Associate Professor (Thu Apr 17, 2008 1:43pm ET)report post
by Dave Walker, Ph.D.
I saw the docudrama film years ago and would really like to obtain a copy. I teach advanced psychopathology to doctoral graduate students in psychology.

So far no one has explained another mystery beyond the twins-- WHY is this movie so hard to find? I wrote Jon Amiel's agent and got no response. I've also searched many catalogs and had our librarian comb video collections across the country-- NO LUCK!

Any help provided is greatly appreciated. Thanks.
Comment on this...

Re:The Silent Twins (Wed Aug 10, 2005 12:07pm ET)report post
by Hannah
I was intrigued by the story of these two as well. I gather that the person who was unaware of Jennifer's fate did not read the updated version of the book,which told you at the end how Jennifer dropped dead for no apparant reason. The story is fascinating for its sheer mystery. A lot of people ascertain that Jennifer was the 'evil' twin and that the only way the two's struggle could end WAS for her to die. Sounds kind of cruel to me,but it could be one explaination. I'm curious to know how June managed to assert herself following her twin's death but I guess that's none of the world's business.
Comment on this...

Untitled (Fri Jul 22, 2005 9:42pm ET)report post
by W. Kosters
hoi
years ago I saw the BBC-documentry 'the silent twins; without my shadow'and i am looking for it. I also read the book and i am very intrigued by the story. I'm dutch, so please overlook the language-mistakes...
willie
Comment on this...

arghh help! (Thu Jul 7, 2005 3:19am ET)report post
by natascha
i love this book, can someone please help me find the movie, doco watever! pls
Comment on this...

Spirit World (Fri May 6, 2005 3:27pm ET)report post
by Graham White
I myself have always been a little reclusive so i was particularly interested in the book about june and jennifer. Perhaps jennifer had the last laugh as she is no longer in this rotten world.
What i would like to ask june is, Do you believe in the spirit world, and if so do you make regular contact with jennifer?
Please e mail me june and let me know.
All the best
Graham -----------
Comment on this...

DIFFRENT VIEW (Wed Apr 20, 2005 7:16pm ET)report post
by ENRAGED
I don't feel at all sorry for the twins. Reading th ebook the silent twins enraged me. I thought it was cruel of them to play such a joke on the world by acting mute without any sole purpose they pretend to be mentally ill by yet they have enought knowledge to experiment on drugs, sex , and even arsony. Tehy pretended to be mentally ill when in reality everyone who tried to help them they mocked them in what they called a"game". I wouldn't have wasted my time trying to treat two pwoplw who refused to even try and then blame eachother for thei failures in not being married, social, etc. they are to blame.
Comment on this...
Re: DIFFRENT VIEW (Thu Sep 15, 2005 1:48am ET)report post
by Jackie
Wow - you are really being judgemental aren't you? So, by your reckoning, anyone with a mental illness is just being selfish huh? Do you think the twins enjoyed the teasing and abuse they experienced at school? Being cut off from the rest of the world? Did you even read the book properly or do you have insufficient empathy to see the suffering they endured? Please - get some compassion.
Comment on this...

so interesting! (Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:08pm ET)report post
by Kennesia Martin
I found the book so intriguing that at the boarding school I attend, I told all my friends about the book. The beginning of the story, a teacher said he only knew three evil people and Jennifer was one of them. Well, I believe that Jennifer was not evil but just more controlling because of the inequality she saw in June's intellectual ability and other things where June was a tiny bit better. When Jennifer passed away I felt sorry for June and relieved at the same time because June could start showing outward affection. Throughout the story I wanted to intervene and put both of the twins out of their internal battle.
I actually have friends who could understand how June and Jennifer could have such a dependance on each other, but yet could never fully understand. No-one can fully understand but June and Jennifer. So although the book was very informative, sometimes it is best hearing someone's story from their own mouth.

So June if you get this, I would love to hear from you to see how you are and ask you some questions. Such as if your parents believed twins were a good or bad sign or if their beliefs were rooted in the Caribbean way of thinking. I'm from England too and my parents are from the Caribbean so we have things in common.

Please e-mail me June if you get this. So i love daron i went ahead and called a
Comment on this...
Re: so interesting! (Mon Jan 31, 2005 1:27pm ET)report post
by svscoa
A few years ago, I saw an article on June Gibbons and a then-current photo of her. Significant weight gain, butchy Afro haircut, silly smile on her face. Apparently, she lives in Wales near her old hometown with a female partner. Medicated with psychotropics and doing as well as can be expected for a semi-functional psychotic.

Reportedly, Broadmoor's primary diagnosis on the twins was some type of major schizophrenia. Totally incurable. There is no doubt in British or US psychiatrists' minds that the twins were criminally insane and quite dangereous.

I wush June well, but would not want to give her my address for any reason.


Comment on this...
Re: so interesting! (Mon Jun 23, 2008 5:38am ET)report post
by Lorna
so judgemental and inaccurate assumption
Comment on this...

Loving the book (Mon Dec 27, 2004 8:04pm ET)report post
by jamiecox
i just want to say this book was a very good book i just loved it and i feel so sorry for them for having to go through that ordeal and i am extremely pleased to hear that june is alive and of course out of broadmoor i just hope she will live a better life now
Comment on this...

Trying to contact June Gibbons (Sun Dec 26, 2004 7:33pm ET)report post
by Christina Walker-Potts
I read your story years ago and recently went online to see if there was an udate on you.
I was shocked and saddened to hear that Jennifer had passed away. Life can sometimes be so unfair. I would so much like to correspond with you and this is the only way I know how to try. Please e-mail me June if you get this message.

Wanting to be your friend,

Christina Walker-Potts
Comment on this...

June and Jennifer Gibbons (Wed Apr 21, 2004 7:37pm ET)report post
by Pat Schiff
I just read an article written by Marjorie Wallace for the Observer on July 13, 2003, in which Marjorie, writing about Ladan and Laleh Bijani, also discusses June and Jennifer Gibbons.
Sadly Jennifer died very shortly after she and June left Broadmoor. The cause of death was a sudden acute myocarditis (an inflammation of the heart muscle). June now leads a quiet life, residing near her parents.
More details can be read at www.guardian.co.uk/iran/story/0,12858,997276,00.html
Comment on this...
Re: June and Jennifer Gibbons (Thu Jun 17, 2004 6:19am ET)report post
by Ailyn Austria Galinato
I have a copy of The Silent Twins by Marjorie Wallace I was really astound by what happened to them... they are both very talented and the elective mutism they possessed can be cured if they had had just an open communication with their immediate family.

I feel sad for them...sometimes life is so unfair! But, I'm happy to know that June now is having a normal life.

PS. To June Gibbons:

If you find this page please send me an email. Thanks in advance! You take care and God bless you!
Comment on this...
Re: Re: June and Jennifer Gibbons (Thu Aug 5, 2004 9:53pm ET)report post
by verna j rivers
June, If you read this note, please contact me. I am so sorry for your lost. Several years ago when I read the book (for the first time), my heart felt for you and Jennifer.
Comment on this...

Next Page >>
 

Post a new comment

name*:   Remember me

* = required

e-mail:
title*:
comments*:

smileys:
:-)  :-D  :-(

Never include your phone number or address in your comment. Be nice. Please refrain from inappropriate language and personal attacks. We reserve the right to delete your entry without notice. Your IP address is logged. Came across something that you or others might find offensive? Let us know by clicking on the 'report post' link.