The Cherry Orchard (1999)

2 historical performancs

c'est une excellente idée de nous offrir ces deux versions de La Cerisaie
dans la première, Judi Dench joue le rôle de la jeune Ania
dans la deuxième, plus récente, c'est elle qui joue le rôle central
cela fait de ce DVD un objet historique fascinant November 30, 2008

Boooooring

I'm also a big fan of Judi Dench and I do not fault her acting in either of these productions, I watched both. I prefer the 1981 version, which is strange for me because I always prefer an older version of almost anything but the 1962 version was lifeless although I enjoyed Judi as Anya better then the Anya in the newer version . Also the sound was not very good on this DVD.
This was my first Chekhov play and I guess his writing is not up my alley! (sorry Chekhov fans)
I agree with the reviewer who said the story plot was hard to follow, dry, and DULL. December 13, 2007

Chekhov brought to life

The cast in both versions handle Chekhov's material with the utmost care. The direction in the 1962 M. St.Denis version is rather beautiful. One can't really go wrong with a cast like Gielgud, Ashcroft, Dench, Tutin, etc. They all just give the most stunning performances of this material. Chekhov is actually incredibly timeless, and the cast is absolutely thrilling to watch. Richard Eyre's 1981 version is a bit more stoic, but his choice to bring Judi Dench on as Mdme. Ranevsky was like finishing a luxurious necklace with the Hope Diamond. Judi Dench has the unbelievable ability to let a story and character filter through herself like an incredibly adept translator. Both of these versions are magical. The more theatrical version of 1962, and the "made for film" version of 1981. Both should not be missed, if even only for the experience of the remarkable performances, but certainly for the well handled telling of the genius Chekhov. July 9, 2007

the astonishing growth of a great actor

Watching Judi Dench play Anna in the earlier production and then Madame Ranevsky twenty years later offers an opportunity to see a good actor become great. Her mature skills are extraordinary, but her ability twenty years earlier to play with such art is truly amazing. Also, each production of The Cherry Orchard is great, entirely worthy of Chekhov's greatest play. May 12, 2007

Very Displeased - Husband Says 2 1/2 Stars

As an avid collector of Judi Dench movies, etc. I was very let down. There was so much hype in advertising this, I couldn't wait to see it. After receiving the DVD's we had to watch them three times before we could make any sense at all of them. Here you have the Stage Play, both the Originial and the New Version. I don't want to critique too strongly, I love theatres and stage Acting, going to broadway shows, but this reminded me of a night we went to a small town Community Theatre, and left half way thru the show. (( Please don't Misunderstand, it was really bad, others left also, I Love going to Community theatres ))

I am not critiquing the Actors and Actresses, but the original Dry, Dull, Not Interesting, Yet Complicated Story Plot, which was very hard to follow. If a friend asked my opinion, I would tell them to look at a rental before they decide to buy it. May 12, 2007

More reviews at Amazon.com ...