Winter Passing (2004)

Winter Passing

I thought this movie had interesting characters. It is a little on the dark side of human nature and a relationship between a father and daughter. The actors do a marvelous job in their portrayal of characters. The story line kept my interest throughout. June 14, 2008

One of the best movies I've seen in years.

I actually first came across this movie by accident one night when searching for movies involving Michigan on my DVR. It came up in the search results as being set in Michigan, so I recorded it just for that reason. I never knew the movie would end up becoming one of the best movies I'd ever seen.

To my knowledge, the first time I had seen anything Zooey Deschenel did was in last year's Sci Fi movie The Tin Man. She was good in that, but her performance there can't hold a candle to her performance in Winter Passing. She plays a the daughter of two authors that grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula who sort of just "left" home to find her way in New York. After her mom dies, a few events end with her going back to Michigan to see her dad, played by Ed Harris. She's not so shocked to find her dad has become a self-absorbed alcoholic, seemingly giving up on life after the death of his wife.

The movie sort of plays out as a coming of age movie, but from many different (and sometimes odd) angles. Zooey's character seems to not really care about much of anything except the here and now, her dad seems to dwell on the past and emotions between the two are a mish mash of regret, despair, depression and sadness. There may be some love in there, but you have to really dig deep to find it.

Winter Passing is dark... the atmosphere is gloomy and until you get to the end, you won't find yourself laughing too much at anything that goes on. Except for Will Ferrell's character. While not in the film all that much, Ferrell plays a character living with Ed Harris who is at once shy, overly-religious and kind. His character is the one and only comic relief you'll find throughout most of the film, and he plays the part so well, it's s shame he isn't more well known for this part than some of his other roles. If you're reading this and thinking "Ah, I hatye Will Ferrell's brand of comedy", don't fret... this is a character I guarentee you've never seen him play before. He's... disturbed, to say the least.

I've seen some people on this forum talk about the cat scene. They are making it out like she just kills the cat for no reason, but she isn't. I won't give it away, but there's TWO different reason she did what she did to the cat. It apparently made an imapct on some cat-loving viewers, so the makers of the movie obviously accomplished what they set out to do.

Like I said, I recorded this movie, but it was so good I bought it. If the beginning of this movie where Zooey's character was in new York had been cut by 10 or so minutes, this would have been a perfect movie. As it is, it still is damn near perfect. March 7, 2008

Depressing

I thought this was a depressing film. Ferrell was good, but the character of Resse, her father, and others was so bleak and dreary that it truly made this a miserable evening. Full stop. March 1, 2008

Coming home to daddy J. D. Salinger

Winter passing is yet another answer from a filmmaker who wishes there could be a film of Catcher in the Rye. I think Sallinger, quite inadvertently, by not allowing his seminal work that generation after generation discovers, to become a film, has inspired far more great cinema that had he just allowed it to happen years ago. Winter Passing is one such film. Had Sallinger allowed Catcher in the Rye to become a film, this work of simple sentimental art wold never have been made. For that I am happy Sallinger has stuck to his guns.

Other films like The Royal Tenenbaums and Finding Forester are two other films that come to mind as great works that fall along the same lines.

Zooey Deschanel, who is my favorite beautiful face out there right now also delivers a great performance. She is a real actress, not just a pretty head. Even her name was probably inspired by Salinger's Franny and Zooey. She was perfect in this film. Will Ferrell also gives a great subdued performance. He is obviously trying to make that transition to drama just as Adam Sander has been attempting. This was a good step in the right direction.

The film is one of those that requires re-watching again and again. It's a pleasure. February 6, 2008

Underrated

This is my first movie review, and I chose this one because I believe it has recieved unfairly poor reviews, even by actual movie critics. It is a tremendous movie in general. Strangely engaging and moving, with some excellent performances with all those involved. Harris and Deschanel are spectacular and Will Ferrell's first (and only as far as i know) performance in a drama was superb. He plays his character to a tee. A lonely, subdued, quirky and somewhat strange and random guy. Still manages to be quite funny in some scenes ie) Talking about his Christian Rock Group, Punching Pilot. The movie has a very somber and somewhat depressing atmosphere to it. You feel for these characters, especially Deschanel and come to appreciate the fact that no family is normal and perfect. We all have our faults and have made mistakes, but love and appreciation for what we have manages to come through. A refreshing movie if you ask me, and one that needs to be seen and appreciated by more people July 30, 2007

More reviews at Amazon.com ...