The Moonstone (1997)

Decent but not spectacular

Having just read the book, I found the movie somewhat tedious. The movie cuts a lot out but moves at a faster pace than the novel, which is overall a good move though at times I think it loses something in the editing. Not a lot of substance to it, but it's okay. If you've never read the book, it might be confusing or perhaps just more interesting because you don't know how it will end. Overall, it's a good movie but probably not one I'll watch again and again. I'd suggest renting it rather than buying it. June 15, 2008

Don't Accept Stolen Diamonds with Curses on Them!

The moral of the story is certainly one difficult to argue, and this film adaptation of Wilkie Collins' book is fantastic with lush filming, beautiful homes, excellent acting and an intriguing plot. English aristocracy was known for "correct" behavior at all times. One's reputation was of utmost importance. Damage to one's reputation could ruin one's life and worse-- this is the foundation of the unlikely but entertaining mystery that is at the center of The Moonstone.

The characters are all well done and even the bizarre detective with his surety, sideburns, and affection for roses seems completely authentic. Both my husband and I enjoyed this film completely and recommend it highly. English upper-crust society was very much about the keeping up of appearances. Everybody keeps their appearances in The Moonstone until things go very much astray. Excellent. March 28, 2008

The Moonstone

Enjoyable. As this was made about ten years ago it is interesting to see Greg Wise and Keely Hawes together early in their careers. Excellent British cast. February 15, 2008

Kind of mediocre.

I was disappointed in this piece. I was hoping for a romantic period piece that I could watch on rainy days, but that's not what I got. It's a early rough-edged mystery, with some cringe-worth detective sluthing. It's does have a wonderful cast, with some recognizable faces who do a fairly good job. August 27, 2007

A Who-Dunnit Detective Film.

Attractive lead actors perform an average script of a period murder-mystery.

Technically good in costumes, lighting, and attractive sets. If you like a light Whodunnit; you may like this. As good as anything on TV today. The detective is interesting, and his sleuthing has some interest. The story holds your attention; therefore, maybe 3-stars for some people (I rate 2-stars, if I do not keep it to watch again years later).

5-star Mystery DVD's are: "Road to Avonlea-Season 3", episode: "A Dark and Stormy Night", starring Christopher Reeve; or the modern, clever, murder-mystery series "Columbo", Seasons 1-7 (have not seen the other seasons).

This did not have what I was looking for, some adventure, more believability, more charm, and more cleverness.

The sets are attractively "staged"; rather than sets that take you there. Has pleasant characters; but not deep. Some good humor personality with the servants. April 6, 2007

More reviews at Amazon.com ...