My Own Private Idaho - Criterion Collection (1991)

River & Keanu make a great team - a classic!

I'm a major River Phoenix fan. He was the finest actor of my generation - simple as that. He had that rare ability to make you feel...in every film he did. IMO, this is some of his greatest work. You can almost touch his vunerability - that's how powerful it is. You forget your watching River...he totally becomes his character Mike. And of all the Keanu Reeves movies I've seen, I thought he did some of his best acting here. He and River were a great team. They had done a film before this together and their deep affection for each other and their friendship is clear - it shows through. It may have been working with his good friend, River, that made his acting so great in this film. They worked well off each other - and it showed. When I first rented this movie, I didn't get it...thought it was so wierd...and wondered why in the hell would River and Keanu do a film like this??? That was my mistake - I didn't give it a fair chance the first time...only half heartedly watching. But a few months later, I rented it again...feeling I had missed something the first time around - and I'm so glad I did. This is a raw, messy masterpiece that absolutely deserves your attention. River's performance alone is worth the price of the dvd. It touched me...made me laugh and cry. this movie will stay with you for awhile because River's performance is so hauntingly good. The ending was sad to me. But I think it's what you make of it. To me, River will always be searching...and that was Keanu's character that drives by in the end and picks him up. Have a nice day! November 24, 2008

charlotte lmp

This was an independent movie which was visually beautiful but a bit hard for me to understand. It was one of the beautiful River Phoenix's last roles and he was so great in the character, almost too natural and brilliant. October 30, 2008

A Movie Like No Other That I Never Tire of Watching

I had bought the original version of "My Own Private Idaho" on VHS a number of years ago. (It was probably within a year or two of first seeing it). Essentially, it describes the lives of teens and young adults struggling to survive on the streets of an area (which I, of course, am forgetting now) in Oregon.(More than anything, the focus is on young men who are gay or heterosexual trying to survive as street hustlers, having sex with strangers for money. It's gritty, intriguing-there are numerous characters, many of which have small roles and I didn't recognize them from anything. The two main roles of Scott and Mike are played by Keanu Reeves and River Phoenix, and, I believe this was performed beautifully by the both of them. (The bassist from the group Red Hot Chili Peppers, Flea, plays a small part in it as well.) As much as I love so many things about the movie, it did feel sort of, unfinished, perhaps with the way in which it ended, but, perhaps it was meant to end on that note. I don't know. For the most part, though, a pretty amazing film that should not be missed!! August 31, 2008

Keanu and River's Excellent Adventure

I used to be a film critic for KALX in Berkeley, and I interviewed Gus Van Sant for his movie, Mala Noche. It was a low budget black and white art film based on a semi-autobiographical novel by a writer who was kind of obsessed with young Mexican immigrants. In the interview he told me that the writer visited the set but he made the cast nervous. With edgy material like that, I never expected Gus to break through to the main stream, but Drug Store Cowboy did pretty well, and then he got a chance to make My Own Private Idaho. It still seems like a bit of a fluke that a film like this got made.

The film is set in Portland and concerns two street hustlers, Scott Favor (Keanu Reeves) and Mike Waters (River Phoenix). They do travel to Idaho at one point, in search of Mike's mother, and also make their way to Italy. The title comes from the B-52's song. The 'plot' is loosely (very loosely) based on William Shakespeare's Henry the IV part 1. Scott would be analogous to Hal, The Prince of Wales. Hal (the future Henry V) has forsaken the Royal Court to waste his time in taverns with low companions. This makes him an object of scorn to the nobles and calls into question his royal worthiness. Hal's chief friend and foil in living the low life is Sir John Falstaff. Fat, old, drunk, and corrupt as he is, he has a charisma and a zest for life that captivates the Prince, born into a world of hypocritical pieties and mortal seriousness.

Prince Hal and his companions Falstaff, Poins, Bardolph, and Peto, are streetwise but pound-foolish; and these rogues manage to paint over this grim history in the colours of comedy. While joking, drinking, and whoring with his pals he finds himself embroiled in a highway robbery, which is the chief means that Falstaff and his minions have of supporting themselves. Hal is not, however, a pawn of these fellows, but rather coolly keeps his head, does not participate directly and later returns all the money taken. Rather early in the play, in fact, Hal informs us that his riotous time will soon come to a close, and he will re-assume his rightful high place in affairs by showing himself worthy to his father and others through some (unspecified) noble exploits. Though Hal believes a sudden change of manner will amount to a greater reward and acknowledgment of prince-ship, and in turn 'earn' him respect from the members of the court.

Bob Pigeon is the MOPI equivelent of Falstaff:

Bob Pigeon: Scott. When you inherit your fortune, on your twenty-first birthday, let's see... how far away is this?
Scott Favor: One week away, Bob, just one more week.
Bob Pigeon: Let's not call ourselves robbers, but Diana's foresters. Gentlemen of the shade. Minions of the Moon. Men of good government.
Scott Favor: [under his breath] When I turn twenty-one, I don't want any more of this life. My mother and father will be surprised at the incredible change. It will impress them more when such a ****-up like me turns good than if I had been a good son all along. All the past years I will think of as one big vacation. At least it wasn't as boring as schoolwork. All my bad behavior I'm going to throw away to pay my debt. I will change when everybody expects it the least.

Bob is kind of a father figure to the street hustlers. He is portrayed by William Richert, who wrote the novel and screenplay, and directed River Phoenix in the 1988 movie, A Night in the Life of Jimmy Reardon. If Bob is Falstaff, and Scott Favor is Prince Hal, then Mike Waters is either Poins, Bardolph, or Peto, take your pick.

Actually, at first there were two seperate scenarios. Mike's story is combined with the Shakespeare/Scott Favor saga in the manner of the cut up techniques of William S. Burroughs. Van Sant got the idea to combine them after watching Orson Welles' Chimes at Midnight. I think that Bob says at one point, "I have heard the chimes at midnight."

Anyway, you get the idea that this is a weird film. As if it wasn't weird enough, Mike Waters also suffers from narcolepsy, a disease that causes him to fall asleep in stressful situations. Often he wakes up in the middle of the road somewhere.

Mike Waters: I'm a connoisseur of roads. I've been tasting roads my whole life. This road will never end. It probably goes all around the world.

Directed by Gus Van Sant:

Elephant (2003)
Finding Forrester (2000)
Psycho (1998)
Good Will Hunting (1997)
To Die For (1995)
Even Cowgirls Get the Blues (1993)
My Own Private Idaho (1991)
Drugstore Cowboy (1989) (as Gus Van Sant Jr.)
Mala Noche - Criterion Collection (1985)


Films of Keanu Reeves

The Private Lives of Pippa Lee (2009) (filming) .... Chris
The Day the Earth Stood Still (2008) (post-production) .... Klaatu
Street Kings (2008) .... Detective Tom Ludlow
The Lake House (2006) .... Alex Wyler
Constantine (2005) .... John Constantine
Thumbsucker (2005) .... Perry Lyman
Ellie Parker (2005) .... Dogstar
Something's Gotta Give (2003) .... Julian Mercer
The Matrix Revolutions (2003) .... Neo
The Matrix Reloaded (2003) .... Neo
Hard Ball (2001) .... Conor O'Neill
Sweet November (2001) .... Nelson Moss
The Gift (2000) .... Donnie Barksdale
The Watcher (2000/I) .... David Allen Griffin
The Replacements (2000) .... Shane Falco
Me and Will (1999) .... Dogstar/Himself
The Matrix (1999) .... Neo
The Devil's Advocate (1997) .... Kevin Lomax
The Last Time I Committed Suicide (1997) .... Harry
Feeling Minnesota (1996) .... Jjaks Clayton
Chain Reaction (1996) .... Eddie Kasalivich
A Walk in the Clouds (1995) .... Paul Sutton
Johnny Mnemonic (1995) .... Johnny Mnemonic
Speed (1994/I) .... Officer Jack Traven
Little Buddha (1993) .... Siddhartha
Even Cowgirls Get the Blues (1993) .... Julian Gitche
Freaked (1993) (uncredited) .... Ortiz the Dog Boy
Much Ado About Nothing (1993) .... Don John
Dracula (1992) .... Jonathan Harker
My Own Private Idaho (1991) .... Scott Favor
Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey (1991) .... Ted Logan / Evil Ted
Point Break (1991) .... FBI Special Agent John 'Johnny' Utah
Providence (1991) .... Eric
Tune in Tomorrow... (1990) .... Martin Loader
I Love You to Death (1990) .... Marlon James
Jesse Walker
Parenthood (1989) .... Tod Higgins
Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure (1989) .... Ted Logan
Life Under Water (1989) (TV) .... Kip
Dangerous Liaisons (1988) .... Le Chevalier Raphael Danceny
The Prince of Pennsylvania (1988) .... Rupert Marshetta
Permanent Record (1988) .... Chris Townsend
The Night Before (1988) .... Winston Connelly
River's Edge (1986) .... Matt

Films of River Phoenix

Sneakers (1992) .... Carl Arbegast was portrayed by River Phoenix.
Dogfight (1991) .... Eddie Birdlace is a marine about to ship out to Viet Nam in 1963.
Indiana Jones & the Last Crusade - Widescreen Edition (1989) .... After playing Young Indy he became very close friends with Harrison Ford.
Running on Empty (1988) .... Danny Pope/Michael Manfield were played by River, and he was nominated for both an Oscar and a Golden Globe.
The Mosquito Coast (1986) .... Charlie Fox was played by River in another award winning performance.
Stand By Me (Special Edition) (1986) .... Chris Chambers was played by River in another award winning performance.

Scott Favor: When you wake up, wipe the slugs off your face. Be ready for a new day!


July 4, 2008

Discovering America - One State at a Time

What a stunning film.

Lush greenery and slow drives across rural America collide with the gritty slime and sensuality of the big city in this epic film that propelled both Keanu Reeves and River Phoenix to cinematic glory. While other reviewers might concentrate on the story, I wanted to point out just how *gorgeous* this film looks on any format. The director had an eye for the environment, to be sure, and his overhead shots (especially the poignant climax) should be lessons in film-making to any aspiring film student.

The breakthrough performance here is by River Phoenix, whose character goes from stiff hustler to gooey eyed boy-in-love, all the while nursing specific medical ailments. His portrayal is multi-layered and flawless, and he is going to forever be remembered for this role. Keanu Reeves is cast as a slightly more world-wise character who is torn between his feelings for his friend as well as his obligation to himself. Yes, many people have said that this is a movie about `nothing', but what a beautiful movie about nothing it is.

The Criterion Discs do special justice to the film because this is actually a movie that should be seen on a big screen. On a television set, some of the more soaring visuals are reduced to pretty sights that don't pack a punch as much as they could. If you have a big screen, this film is made frame-for-frame for such a format. I highly recommend this film to both old and new viewers - despite the great storyline, the visuals in this film are just breathtaking.

Five Stars.

March 28, 2008

More reviews at Amazon.com ...