The Sons of Katie Elder (1965)

Great Classic Western

This was a birthday gift for my brother and he was so happy. The quality was good and we really enjoyed watching the Duke July 21, 2008

Big Bad John

The Duke is John Elder,a man with a reputation with a gun,he's back in town for his mothers funeral where all the Elder brother's eventually meet to find out the status of Katie Elders estate she may have left behind for her sons.a good plot,lots of gunplay,John Wayne at his best as usual,Dean Martin is good as Tom Elder,though I've seen him in better roles as the drunk character,Dude,in Rio Bravo.To tell you how tough the Duke really was,Wayne always insisted on doing his own stunts as in this movie after recently undergoing lung cancer surgery(the removal of half of one lung.)A prime example of the Toughness of John Wayne.The Duke once said,courage is being scared but saddling up anyway.I rate Son's of Katie Elder,four stars for the movie itself,and a extra star for the remastered video on this Paramount dvd,what a picture!,also,you can't beat the price. June 16, 2008

Great screenplay! Great soundtrack! Unpredictable and engaging throughout the entire film.

What more can you want in a movie? In my book this is one of the best movies of the 1960's. As the story unfolds the plot keeps you and the characters are fun and remarkably developed which is why I consider this one of the best screenplays ever and I am surprised by the lack of recognition it has achieved on that level. April 6, 2008

Not a great Waynestern, but a good one with very enjoyable twists

This is a different sort of Western for John Wayne. While he has a big reputation as a gunfighter, he spends the film avoiding fighting as much as he can. Wayne also has fewer action sequences in the film. This may simply be due to the plot of the movie, or it may have been his recover from lung cancer surgery and treatment that he had in 1964 and had delayed the shooting of the film until 1965. Wayne insisted on doing all his own stunts even though it had only been four months since he had the cancerous lung removed.

John Wayne, Dean Martin, Earl Holliman, and Michael Anderson Jr. play, respectively, John, Tom, Matt, and Bud Elder. They have come back to Clearwater to attend their mother, Katie's funeral. She was a widely loved, admired, hard working, tough, and sometimes sly woman (we are told she sold a man a blind horse once, and she also wrote a horse rancher that she would like a hundred or two hundred of his horses on credit to sell). John's reputation is such that he watches the funeral from up on a hill. His three brothers had waited for him at the train (along with Sheriff Billy and his hot headed deputy). However, the only person that got off the train was a menacing looking stranger. We later learn his name is Curly (WONDERFULLY played by George Kennedy) and he is a gunfighter who was hired by Morgan Hastings (James Gregory).

As the brothers try to settle up Katie's estate they learn that there was something shady surrounding the loss or sale or transfer of Katie's 1,200 acre ranch to Morgan Hastings, who seems bent on buying up and building the town, with him owning it all. They discover that their father had supposedly lost the ranch in a poker game, which seemed somewhat in character. But his being shot very shortly after this game was supposed to have taken place raises their suspicions. Sheriff Billy Wilson (Paul Fix) at first tries to simply get the brothers to move on, but he keeps getting closer to the truth of Bass Elder's death. When Billy is shot, his hot headed deputy assumes it was the "Elder Gang" and arrests them without any investigation. The movie heads towards its climax and a good one it is.

Martha Hyer plays Martha Gordon who was an old friend of the family and took care of Katie. She is as close to a romantic lead as the movie gets, and it doesn't get very close. Percy Helton did a nice turn in a small role as a shopkeeper who enjoyed doing business with Katie Elder. She bought at his store, but also made dresses for his wife and gave her a couple of guitar lessons. Another interesting aspect of the film is that Wayne was really 57. Katie's tombstone says she was 64. So, how old John Elder was supposed to be (40?) is open to question. Bud is supposed to be 17. The old Western TV show Bonanza had a similar age problem with the oldest sons and Lorne Green.

But this is a classic Waynestern. Not one of the very best, but memorable and enjoyable.

Reviewed by Craig Matteson, Ann Arbor, MI
March 17, 2008

Four Brothers on the loose

This classic Western Flick is the best introduction into this genre.Four Brothers try to find out why their mother was killed.The movie is full of legendary moments like classic shootouts or brawling scenes.It is also an exemple of perfect Type casting and beautiful composed pictures(See Waynes first appearence).The Picture is quiet good in a terrific Scope presentation and the sound ok.Specials are Zero.But a must for any collectors. February 25, 2008

More reviews at Amazon.com ...