The Newton Boys (1998)

A little slow at times, but overall a very good movie

It's hard to make a successful movie based upon real people and true situations. But this movie does an admirable job of it. I'd forgotten all about the Newton Boys until I saw this movie recently (just loved the interviews played during the credits, definitely added to the entire movie). Very good acting by all key players. Loved the music from that era. August 25, 2008

No gravitation for these Newtons but a lot of ethical levitation

The film is very banal. Bank robbers and postal train robbers, déjà vu, blasé, passé. Nothing particularly interesting or exciting. Yet the film has a slight flaw that makes it maybe of some interest. These bank robbers and postal train robbers survived the whole business in 1924, got through the trial with rather light sentences and they most of them died of old age fifty or so years later after giving, for some of them, some TV interviews about that profession of their young age. Then that was not a film but a fictionalized documentary. Shucks! Those who got the heaviest sentences were the few real profiteers who were the real organizers behind those young cowboys who got misled, by their own dream, into getting by force the money they desired to have. But the worst part in all that story is that they got caught on their last venture, the postal train robbery, because one of the gang of brothers shot another member of that brotherly gang because he did not stick to what he was supposed to do, went on the other side of the train and got frightened by someone who did not have the identifying hat they were all supposed to wear. A mistake, another mistake and the whole venture came to a stop, though they apparently did not recuperate all the money, neither the authorities, not the Newton Boys, because the part that was hidden away by one of them was done so under the influence of alcohol, not the money of course, but the Newton Boy who was supposed to bury it and he could never, so he says at least, remember where it was. If you are not afraid of the strong cowboy Texan accent of these boys, you can watch it and entertain yourself with the dream of what you could do with three million 1924 dollars. I guess you would favor buying a new hybrid car to be economical and nice with the planet.

Dr Jacques COULARDEAU, University Paris Dauphine, University Paris 1 Pantheon Sorbonne & University Versailles Saint Quentin en Yvelines
May 29, 2008

fun for all ages

I liked that this movie is based on true story. The best part is at the end during the interview. January 5, 2008

A light and almost comical twist on the western...

`The Newton Boys' is not your typical western. Running more in the lines of `American Outlaws' then say `Unforgiven', `The Newton Boys' is in all respects a `fun film'. It doesn't take itself too seriously. It jokes around and rests heavy on comedic timing and a loud atmosphere. The cast is young and fresh as apposed to mature and polished. They are the `it' boys of the given year, cast to draw in a slew of teen viewers and boost ticket sales. This is not an adult drama but more like a teen dramedy. None of this is a bad thing; it's just a different thing. I expected something more when I initially saw this when it was released, but after watching this again the other night I can see it for what it is and thus enjoy it even though it is not as good as it could have been, had it gone the more artistic route.

The film chronicles the infamous Newton boys, four brothers who became the most successful bank robbers in history. They were not your typical heathens either. They never killed anybody; they lived near respectable lives and never turned a fellow in. They were likable people. I'm sure they had flaws but this film is not about embellishing them for our enjoyment, this film is about making them as charming and approachable as possible, and they do that. The very idea of casting Matthew `charming' McConaughey as the lead is a dead give away for the films intent. So Willis, Joe, Jess and Dock rob nearly eighty banks and would have gotten away with it entirely if they hadn't decided to take one `last' job, a mail train, a robbery that got so botched they almost lost their lives but in the end just lost their fortune.

The acting is not too shabby considering the cast. In fact Vincent D'Onofrio, who is arguably the best overall actor in the bunch despite his lack of `star power', has very little screen time in comparison to his co-stars yet the film still moves along fine. Casting McConaughey as a Texas cowboy was smart since that's kind of what he is. He is always charming even if he has less talent than most and here he uses his charm to help us forget he's riding fame on his looks. Skeet Ulrich is decent as the apprehensive Joe, a far cry from his more famous role as Neve Campbell's killer boyfriend in `Scream'. Julianna Margulies does her best to survive the at times horrific dialog and Dwight Yoakam does all he can to remain memorable in a film that doesn't care much for him. The true highlight of this film though is Ethan Hawke who just nails his performance as Jess. He's hilarious and enthralling. In fact you can't keep your eyes off of him. By far he gives the best performance of the bunch.

In the end `The Newton Boys' is not a masterpiece but it is not a waste of time either. It's not the type of film you may be expecting considering the `darkness' of more current westerns but it has a `fun' factor and is at times purely delightful. It's as charming as its stars and as entertaining as can be expected. At times the dialog is rough, but it's nothing to mull over. Just sit back and relax and enjoy have a rootin'-tootin' good time. December 11, 2007

What's not to like?

I saw this on HBO recently when I was home sick. What a fun farce! The four Newton boys and a safecracker manage to bumble through 80 bank robberies. But things get serious when they try to pull of a "big" job.

The acting is outstanding, but Dwight Yoakum and Skeet Ulrich turn in phenomenal supporting performances. Yoakum plays the hypochondriac safecracker and Ulrich is youngest brother Joe. Ulrich has the most to do as he matures from baby brother to convict, while serving as the conscience, worrier, romantic, and accountant of the group.

The Texas accents were great. Never once were the accents or speech distracting from the movie itself. The music is also perfect for this movie. It intensifies for a moment as something blows up, or you think something bad is about to happen, then it goes back to bum-bump.. dee bum bum bum-bump.

Whoever thought the line "You're mean, you know that?" was dumb, is missing the point. These boys had guns full of bird shot. They had no intention of hurting anyone, and when they were caught in the act and this lady wouldn't shut up, they worst thing they could think to do was call her mean. Hilarious!

I think the film missed some opportunities for character development. Doc was underdeveloped and Vincent D'Onofrio underutilized. There was a subtle resentment from Jess towards Willis that could have been brought out. I didn't like the stylized introduction. But overall this movie was a blast. December 6, 2006

More reviews at Amazon.com ...